+Renegade Knight Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 (edited) If you have a coin, it's going to be on eBay given time. So what's your price? Some of us are worth more than others when it comes to our coins. How high does your coin have to go before you are not disspointed in the price? How high has it gone for a regular auction? Since I don't have a coin yet, I'd be happy if it clears 25 consistantly when I do, and I'd be thrilled to be a member of the 50 and up club. At those prices I'd never be able to afford to buy back my own coin but...that's the way the ball bounces. If it sold for less than 25 I'd wonder what I should have done differently. My plan is that my signature coin (different from a less and less likely 1k coin) would be a cache only coin. No sales, no trades. Edited May 9, 2006 by Renegade Knight Quote
+Team JSAM Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 My plan is that my signature coin (different from a less and less likely 1k coin) would be a cache only coin. No sales, no trades. That would be great but from what I have seen coins like that get taken more often because the only way to get one is to steal it, however they would sell for more on eBay. We are working on a coin right now and want to make a standard one and an LE but not sell the LE save those for FTF prize and droping in caches only no sales or trades. I would love to make a personal coin and not sell it but dont have the money for that. Quote
+Kealia Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 Our coins were cache only - no sales, no trading. Non trackable but the one we put on eBay sold well for a charity. Not sure what's going to come of this thread so I won't post the amount since it seems like it's going to turn into a "my coin sold for more than yours" battle. Hard to tell what drives prices anyway - reputation (Moun10Bike), scarcity of the coin (like ours sort of), design, etc. Quote
+GEO*Trailblazer 1 Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 (edited) My worth and my coins worth are 2 seperate issues. Cause I sure am worth a lot more than anyone can offer. forgot to add I am getting a lot closer to the 50 range. Edited May 9, 2006 by GEO*Trailblazer 1 Quote
+hydnsek Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 Our coins were cache only - no sales, no trading. Non trackable but the one we put on eBay sold well for a charity. Not sure what's going to come of this thread so I won't post the amount since it seems like it's going to turn into a "my coin sold for more than yours" battle. Hard to tell what drives prices anyway - reputation (Moun10Bike), scarcity of the coin (like ours sort of), design, etc. I could look up my Paypal receipt if you like. Seriously, coins sold for charity are always going to bring much more money than personal sales. So, if someone wants to gauge 'coin worth,' it should be based on personal sales. Quote
+tiki Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 I can't figure out why people bid like mad on a coin on ebay when the geocoin in question is still available from the creator! Drives me nuts. Ok - I vented! Tiki Quote
+cqdx Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 I was quite suprised when a Police Geocaching Squad geocoin went for $51 on ebay.. Prices seem to have settled now. Quote
+Eagles61 Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 I can't figure out why people bid like mad on a coin on ebay when the geocoin in question is still available from the creator! Drives me nuts. Ok - I vented! Tiki Totally agree. Someone has one of my silver coins on ebay with a starting bid of almost $3.00 than I have or am selling them at (some are still available). He is also charging $2.00 shipping, which I included. Quote
+Renegade Knight Posted May 9, 2006 Author Posted May 9, 2006 ...forgot to add I am getting a lot closer to the 50 range. You or your coin? Quote
+Renegade Knight Posted May 9, 2006 Author Posted May 9, 2006 ...Seriously, coins sold for charity are always going to bring much more money than personal sales. So, if someone wants to gauge 'coin worth,' it should be based on personal sales. True. The charity coin is as much if not more a question of the person selling the coin. If you trust that person then you would bid more because you are comfortable doing it and comfortable that the money will go where it's supposed to go. Quote
+TEAM 360 Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 Not much, apparently...I put up 3 extra Original Stash Plaque coin/pin sets up on Ebay starting at $12 + $2 for shipping, ran it for 3 days, and that's exactly what I got for them. I guess no one wants them... Quote
+SunshineGang Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 apparently we are worth 26 on ebay SUNSHINEGANG COIN Quote
+hydnsek Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 Not much, apparently...I put up 3 extra Original Stash Plaque coin/pin sets up on Ebay starting at $12 + $2 for shipping, ran it for 3 days, and that's exactly what I got for them. I guess no one wants them... Wow, I'm shocked. I've gotten several trade offers for my one extra - they seemed like a hot property. And they are kwite kewl! Quote
+carleenp Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 Not much, apparently...I put up 3 extra Original Stash Plaque coin/pin sets up on Ebay starting at $12 + $2 for shipping, ran it for 3 days, and that's exactly what I got for them. I guess no one wants them... It isn't that no one wants them, it is that there are more out there and easier to get in trade etc. So they sell for less. Nothing to feel down about there! I figure theme coins like that are kind of meant to be made available to many, since people enjoy coming up with the theme and sharing it. Quote
+GA Cacher Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 Well I have seen our GA Peach coin go for $50, the 2005 GA Appilacian Trail ( non trackable) go for $35, the Ga Stone Mountain $20 and a Black Nickle GA Micro for $28. The Ontarios usually get $15. Quote
+Thrak Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 (edited) Hard to say. Unfortunately, after the tax man hit me, I'm considering selling my favorite coins. Joefrog, Prairie Partners LE Silver (only 75 minted), Kilted Cacher, Geobone, Kilted Cacher Christmas Coin, Gold Geocoin Addicts, 9key, Team Sand Dollar, etc. I really don't want to go there but eBay may be in my future. I have no idea what they are worth in $$$ - they are worth a lot to me and I hate to even consider selling them but I had to put $1400.00 of taxes on a credit card this year so any income is needed. Edited May 10, 2006 by Thrak Quote
+GEO*Trailblazer 1 Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 Hmmm forgot. OH yeah it must be me because I have never sold any item on e-bay. ...Seriously, coins sold for charity are always going to bring much more money than personal sales. So, if someone wants to gauge 'coin worth,' it should be based on personal sales. True. The charity coin is as much if not more a question of the person selling the coin. If you trust that person then you would bid more because you are comfortable doing it and comfortable that the money will go where it's supposed to go. Quote
+AV Dezign Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 Avalanche got a good sale, and it's not even trackable. Black Nickel went for $89 US Silver Antique (Volunteer) went for $96.96 US Quote
ParentsofSAM Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 Mine were on there but for a Buy it now price, just over what I sold them here for to cover the eBay fees. I have not checked to see if others are selling our coin. Quote
+graylling Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 I'm not sure whether I should be insulted or happy about it but I can't remember ever seeing one of my coins on ebay. I only traded or cached mine so as far as I know theres only 2 people that have more than 1 coin. Mind you I don't check ebay every day so it's possible one slipped past. Quote
+BadAndy Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 I auctioned off 45 of mine in a dutch auction that didn't sell during the presale timeframe for $10.00 ea. This may be a good alternative for minters to recoup some of their investment if forum sales went flat before the sales target is met. Alot of cachers are ebayer's and don't visit our forum here. I've seen mine go for as low as $13.00 (already activated) or as high as $52.00. They usually are in the mid $20.00 range. Not many people bought more than 2 from the forum presales, so there isn't many folks with more than 1 at this point. Quote
+Spencersb Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 (edited) One of mine sold for $12, which was 3X what I paid for it, and more than I bid to get it back. I think my design was pretty plain, I made it before the craze really took off, and naively thought a less fancy design would be cheaper to produce. Only had 100 made, though, and I'm down to my last two. Edited May 10, 2006 by Spencersb Quote
+GBOTS Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 We sold one of each of our coins (bronze, shiny silver, and antique v2) and they all did quite well... Quote
+Kealia Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 ...Seriously, coins sold for charity are always going to bring much more money than personal sales. So, if someone wants to gauge 'coin worth,' it should be based on personal sales. True. The charity coin is as much if not more a question of the person selling the coin. If you trust that person then you would bid more because you are comfortable doing it and comfortable that the money will go where it's supposed to go. Both good points (sorry for the late reply). I haven't sold a personal coin on Ebay (except for the one mentioned above for charity) and don't plan to so I can only speculate. maybe.....$5.00? Quote
+Cryptid Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 I won't sell my personal coin on Ebay, but someone else did, and it went for $18.06. I have seen The Legend of Bigfoot go for over $30.00. Quote
+Jeep'en Jumpers Posted May 10, 2006 Posted May 10, 2006 Not much, apparently...I put up 3 extra Original Stash Plaque coin/pin sets up on Ebay starting at $12 + $2 for shipping, ran it for 3 days, and that's exactly what I got for them. I guess no one wants them... Remember the coin I gave you?? Hmmm, don't see any of those 12 dollar coins in my book??? Quote
+TEAM 360 Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 Not much, apparently...I put up 3 extra Original Stash Plaque coin/pin sets up on Ebay starting at $12 + $2 for shipping, ran it for 3 days, and that's exactly what I got for them. I guess no one wants them... Remember the coin I gave you?? Hmmm, don't see any of those 12 dollar coins in my book??? Whatchyoutalkin bout, Willis? I sent your coin today! I feel better already, an Original Stash coin just went for $25+$3.50 shipping on HERE, and it didn't even include the free pin that originally came with it! Quote
+Night Stalker Posted May 13, 2006 Posted May 13, 2006 No one is going to come close to Moun10bikes coins. As far as I know there have been only to to show up on Ebay. the one went for $1700.00. I am not sure what the other sold for. Guess it pays to be famous. Quote
Rupert2 Posted May 13, 2006 Posted May 13, 2006 One of mine sold for $12, which was 3X what I paid for it, and more than I bid to get it back. I think my design was pretty plain, I made it before the craze really took off, and naively thought a less fancy design would be cheaper to produce. Only had 100 made, though, and I'm down to my last two. You did not need the fancy design as yours was a classic to begin with. Definately one of my favorites! I feel like I have gone out of my way to find really good homes for my coins and have tried hard to make sure that no one has more than one. Yeah one will appear on ebay eventually but I HOPE that is years down the road. I am very happy to see that folks are going back to the trade only philosophy. It make it all much more fun, not to mention that you get to correspond with some really cool geocachers! Quote
+The Blind Acorn Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 LOL, took my coin 8 days to show up on ebay. I'm going for $11 right now. If you know of someone bidding on the Blind Acorn coin on there, tell them I have plenty left.... Quote
+Ryder3 & Better Half Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 I was quite suprised when a Police Geocaching Squad geocoin went for $51 on ebay.. Prices seem to have settled now. We got 41.00 for our badge coin! R3 & BH Quote
+Ryder3 & Better Half Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 Not much, apparently...I put up 3 extra Original Stash Plaque coin/pin sets up on Ebay starting at $12 + $2 for shipping, ran it for 3 days, and that's exactly what I got for them. I guess no one wants them... When you list a coin,check to see how many are on auction,you will always do better when there a few,or none up for bids. This coin did very well for us. It is a HUGE Beauty! R3 Quote
+Tharagleb Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 (edited) There are 4 or 5 Vermont geocoins going for $10 to $13 w/shipping right now. They can still be had at the Geocoinstore for $8.63 (shipping included). If the GCstore had sold out already I would go on ebay and undercut all these guys. But I do believe in free enterprise, so I am not upset with them (the ebayers). I hope some day the coins are going for $50 bucks a piece, I might hang on to 20 or 30 for a year or so and see what the market is bearing. [Edited to fix ambiguous reference.] Edited May 26, 2006 by Tharagleb Quote
+Mandollyn Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 (edited) R3&BH - you have made quite a bit on E8AY with these coins... I just posted one of my 2 PEZ coins... I hope your luck, if that's what you want to call it, is with me on this one! If anyone wants me to post any of your geocoins on there, message me! I'll just send the profit to you via PayPal...! Edited May 26, 2006 by Mandollyn Quote
+Ryder3 & Better Half Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 LOL, took my coin 8 days to show up on ebay. I'm going for $11 right now. If you know of someone bidding on the Blind Acorn coin on there, tell them I have plenty left.... You must be talking about us!LOL We have an 11.00 bid on your coin! As middleman dealers we can tell you that this coin is going to do VERY well! We have already sold one for more than that privately.(We also have non-cachers getting your coin!!) SHHHHHHHH!!! Don't tell anyone!LOL! R3 Quote
+Ryder3 & Better Half Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 There are 4 or 5 Vermont geocoins going for $10 to $13 w/shipping right now. They can still be had at the Geocoinstore for $8.63 (shipping included). If the GCstore had sold out already I would go on ebay and undercut all these guys. But I do believe in free enterprise, so I am not upset with them (the ebayers). I hope some day the coins are going for $50 bucks a piece, I might hang on to 20 or 30 for a year or so and see what the market is bearing. [Edited to fix ambiguous reference.] YOU have a great attitude!! I hope it spreads!LOL! This coin is also doing well! R3 Quote
+Evil Chicken Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 An Evil Chicken LE egg went for somewhere in the neigborhood of $35.00 - but all proceeds were donated to So. Jersey Geocaching. More recently, I bought back my own LE egg for 15.00. It's already out the door in trade. Quote
+Ryder3 & Better Half Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 R3&BH - you have made quite a bit on E8AY with these coins... I just posted one of my 2 PEZ coins... I hope your luck, if that's what you want to call it, is with me on this one! If anyone wants me to post any of your geocoins on there, message me! I'll just send the profit to you via PayPal...! Team PEZ coins are one of the hottest out there now! No luck involved,COOL coin,COOL idea=A Winner!! We just look for coins we like,& take a shot!Some win,some don't All part of the fun(Kinda like playing the market) Quote
ATMouse Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 Our Allegany State Park Geobash 2006 coin went up on the e-site for a "buy it now" price of $49.95 + shipping and it went in about 3 hours. One is now up for bidding. We sold it for $10 and the profits are for covering the cost of the tent we used at the event and had a bit left over for next year (so we don't have to have the committee members opening their wallets.) It's been (and is currently) interesting, but I'm pretty detacted from it, oddly enough...and I designed it and paid for it. (And will not break even from my pocket, either...<shrug>...it was fun making them.) (And in case that doesn't make sense, I opted to give the "profits" before the coins were all sold. Some got donated and I guess you could say I "paid" for them...) Quote
+Tharagleb Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 Out of curiousity I just checked closed auctions for the Vermont Geocoin, one sold for $33 and other auctions got no bids, I don't get it. Quote
+welch Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 Out of curiousity I just checked closed auctions for the Vermont Geocoin, one sold for $33 and other auctions got no bids, I don't get it. Ebay is like every auction, if you want 'THAT ONE RIGHT THERE, RIGHT NOW!!' you'll pay more than anyone else (thats how an auction works ). If you relax and wait for the next one, or the one after, it may go much cheaper... of course that assumes there will be another one. Quote
hobo dude Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 By what I have seen so far I am worth nothing on ebay. Or if I am worth anything it is bare minimum. Quote
+Lemon Fresh Dog Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 I'll finally be able to reply to this post! It looks as if one of my gold and one of my regular geobones is up on the block Way back in the day they went for $25-$60 -- I wonder what they will fetch (pardon the pun) in todays market? Quote
+geoSquid Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 One of mine sold for $12, which was 3X what I paid for it, and more than I bid to get it back. I think my design was pretty plain, I made it before the craze really took off, and naively thought a less fancy design would be cheaper to produce. Only had 100 made, though, and I'm down to my last two. Although, if it makes you feel better, I personally tend to be willing to pay more for a simpler design with lots of metal, than a complex, mostly-enamel design that makes the coin look like a metal "pog". That's not to say that there aren't very nice coins done with lots of colours and enamel, there are, but my preference is for simpler designs and a more "coin-like" feel and appearance. However, it's not much cheaper to produce a simple design than a complex one. Quote
+geoSquid Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 Out of curiousity I just checked closed auctions for the Vermont Geocoin, one sold for $33 and other auctions got no bids, I don't get it. Ebay is like every auction, if you want 'THAT ONE RIGHT THERE, RIGHT NOW!!' you'll pay more than anyone else (thats how an auction works ). If you relax and wait for the next one, or the one after, it may go much cheaper... of course that assumes there will be another one. This is also something to watch out for on eBay. It applies to anything sold on eBay, not just coins. A couple years ago, I wanted to upgrade my 8" telescope, so I thought "hmm, a used one from eBay should do the trick" and sure enough a search returned many hits... ...almost all of which were going for very close to, or MORE THAN the current MSRP for a new telescope of that make and model, not counting shipping! I even asked some people about this, but all I got back was abuse, so I bought a new one from the manufacturer. I sold my old one on ebay for about 80% of the replacement price and it went fast. All that is a long-winded way of saying that not everyone who buys on ebay really knows what they are doing, and just because someone will pay X for an item doesn't mean the item is really worth X. Quote
+Renegade Knight Posted June 21, 2006 Author Posted June 21, 2006 Out of curiousity I just checked closed auctions for the Vermont Geocoin, one sold for $33 and other auctions got no bids, I don't get it. I don't either, but if you can figure out the timing you can do well as a seller or buyer. Once I was trying to get a fairly rare trading card. (Bazaar of Baghdad, from Magic The Gathering). At the time I only wanted to pay about 8 bucks for them. Auction after auction they would go for 9-12 bucks. Then one day I had a bid on way too many of them and got them all for less than my price. They go for a bit more than that now so my blunder worked out fairly well. Looks like Idaho 2005 has cooled off a bit on eBay. Quote
+prntr1 Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 Just had a Civil War LE go for $55.00 on Ebay, I still have several sitting on my table, and they are available on the website on my sig line for less than $6.00!!!! Quote
+swiser Posted July 23, 2006 Posted July 23, 2006 By what I have seen so far I am worth nothing on ebay. Or if I am worth anything it is bare minimum. I have actually looked for a hobo on Ebay. I love that coin! It reminds me of my son 8 who said he was running away and made a pack like that. But you ar right I guess because no one is selling them. Quote
glennk721 Posted July 23, 2006 Posted July 23, 2006 By what I have seen so far I am worth nothing on ebay. Or if I am worth anything it is bare minimum. I have actually looked for a hobo on Ebay. I love that coin! It reminds me of my son 8 who said he was running away and made a pack like that. But you ar right I guess because no one is selling them. You can buy one here for $5.00 bucks plus shipping. perhaps thats why the demand for them on ebay is low. Glenn http://www.geocoinstore.com/ Quote
+Lemon Fresh Dog Posted July 23, 2006 Posted July 23, 2006 It's been awhile, but it looks as if my geobones go for $35-$50 and my Red-Handed coins go for about $25. They are both coins that were released pre-boom (Geobone was summer 2005, Red-handed was Sept/Oct 2005). Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.