+The Duckers Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 We have quite a few OS Explorer maps for various areas around the country and find them quite invaluable. We need a new one for our forthcoming break in the Forest of Dean as our existing one is quite battered and bruised. Would anyone recommend the Active map against the normal paper one? Quote Link to comment
+little-miss-naughty Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 We have quite a few OS Explorer maps for various areas around the country and find them quite invaluable. We need a new one for our forthcoming break in the Forest of Dean as our existing one is quite battered and bruised. Would anyone recommend the Active map against the normal paper one? memory map Quote Link to comment
+Boidy Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 The active maps are at least waterproof but for the price difference you could buy yourself a decent map case if you haven't got one already. Quote Link to comment
+The Blorenges Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 I've a large collection of the paper Landranger and Explorer maps but haven't used them for ages. I've got Memory Map on my PC and can transfer the maps to my PDA so I've always got a map with me. This normally works with any Windows mobile based device including smart phones. Other things you can do with a PC based map program: Draw routes and tracks, add waypoints, transfer pocket queries to the map and transfer all this into your GPS*. You can print an A4 map out to take with you on a walk. Note that you CANNOT transfer memory maps into a Garmin GPS. They are not supported. To get OS Maps on a Garmin you need the GB Discoverer maps and these work on the Oregon, Dakota and Colorado. The downside is the cost. They don't come cheap. Memory Map for the regions (Wales, Southern England etc) are £50 each. For half the UK (north or south) it is £130. GB Discoverer for the Garmin is £120 for half the UK. I love maps anyway and get great enjoyment out of having the maps on my PC. If you want an OS map to display on the cache page rather than the Google map then you can install a simple script for the Firefox web browser. Click here for more information. Chris (MrB) *If you want to see how to go 'paperless' with Memory Map and a PDA then click here for my resource website. Quote Link to comment
+reddeeps Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 (edited) I buy the paper maps still as we dont have mapping on our gps, I get them from dash4it at 30% less than needed. However for caching I use http://wtp2.appspot.com/wheresthepath.htm as you can upload gpx files to it. This is totally free and uses os maps. And with that and the firefox script os map I am happy. Edited March 16, 2010 by reddeeps Quote Link to comment
+reddeeps Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 As a question then on from this, if I upgraded my reliable garmin III to something newer like a colorado or 60csx (which I fancy) when I then downloaded from gsak, does it have the hints and logs and cache page as well, as at the mo I only get co-ords. (i do have a small pda but cant read it out in the field without my glasses) so I still print the pages off. Also in order to get maps on the newer garmin would I have to buy something else, or are the os maps and footpaths on them? If not I cant see why I would change from my old garmin, as although simple, using it and the above wheres the path program, seems to give me the same. Or am I really missing something. Quote Link to comment
+Bear and Ragged Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 (edited) As a question then on from this, if I upgraded my reliable garmin III to something newer like a colorado or 60csx (which I fancy) when I then downloaded from gsak, does it have the hints and logs and cache page as well, as at the mo I only get co-ords. (i do have a small pda but cant read it out in the field without my glasses) so I still print the pages off. Also in order to get maps on the newer garmin would I have to buy something else, or are the os maps and footpaths on them? If not I cant see why I would change from my old garmin, as although simple, using it and the above wheres the path program, seems to give me the same. Or am I really missing something. Yes. Use the right %codes/settings to give you what you want. (It can be a long explanation, too long for this thread!) Edited March 16, 2010 by Bear and Ragged Quote Link to comment
+Pharisee Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 As a question then on from this, if I upgraded my reliable garmin III to something newer like a colorado or 60csx (which I fancy) when I then downloaded from gsak, does it have the hints and logs and cache page as well, as at the mo I only get co-ords. (i do have a small pda but cant read it out in the field without my glasses) so I still print the pages off.Also in order to get maps on the newer garmin would I have to buy something else, or are the os maps and footpaths on them? If not I cant see why I would change from my old garmin, as although simple, using it and the above wheres the path program, seems to give me the same. Or am I really missing something. Someone else will have to tell you about the Colorado, but as far as the 60CSx is concerned, you can get the full hint but it's a bit 'fiddly'. If the first 80 characters are enough for you then it's a little less so. You can't download the logs or the cache page. Quote Link to comment
+Fianccetto Posted March 16, 2010 Share Posted March 16, 2010 (edited) I think OS is still selling 3 for 2 on maps if you were interested in more than one/ other regions. (Just bought some last week, haven't arrived yet.) If not, I saw another site which sells them individually for a third off. I have a map holder but its annoying to have to keep taking the map out as you get to the edge. you can download hints, description and logs on the Oregon 300 but only as a Premium Member. With basic membership, you just get 'upgrade you membership to receive this information'. Edited March 16, 2010 by Fianccetto Quote Link to comment
+Lydford Locators Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 If we need an OS map of an area ours don't cover, we just pop down the local library where they have lovely laminated ones we can borrow for free. Quote Link to comment
+The Blorenges Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 As a question then on from this, if I upgraded my reliable garmin III to something newer like a colorado or 60csx (which I fancy) when I then downloaded from gsak, does it have the hints and logs and cache page as well, as at the mo I only get co-ords. (i do have a small pda but cant read it out in the field without my glasses) so I still print the pages off. Also in order to get maps on the newer garmin would I have to buy something else, or are the os maps and footpaths on them? If not I cant see why I would change from my old garmin, as although simple, using it and the above wheres the path program, seems to give me the same. Or am I really missing something. You don't need GSAK for the Oregon/Colorado/Dakota as you can put the PQ GPX files straight into it. You get all the cache information (except images) including description, hint and logs. Simples. You can of course use the GSAK macro to export your PQ to the GPS but personally I don't bother. As for maps on any 'mapping' Garmin there are several choices. Garmin's own Topo maps which are no where near as detailed as the OS maps and quite expensive, OpenStreetMaps which are about the same detail as the Topo maps but are free and the OS GB Discoverer maps (full OS maps 1:50K and 1:25K) specifically for the Oregon/Colorado/Dakota but again these are pricey - but very good. I've got Southern England/Wales on my Oregon and it covers from the south all the way up to a line from Blackpool across to the top of Norfolk. Chris (MrB) Quote Link to comment
+reddeeps Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 Thanks for all your replies. Quote Link to comment
+NickandAliandEliza Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 Thanks for all your replies. The 60CSx is brilliant - I've had one for years. I've also got an Oregon. Take a look at the Oregon rather than the Colorado. I know a couple of people who have bought a Colorado and then wished they'd opted for the Oregon. The links are a review (goes on a bit) and a comparison between the two. Quote Link to comment
+The Duckers Posted March 17, 2010 Author Share Posted March 17, 2010 Thanks for all the help. Regarding Memory Map, it is of no help to me as I have an etrex with no immediate intention of upgrading to anything else. Also don't own any type of PDA or other windows mobile type device. I have ordered an Active map. Thanks Reddeeps. I also think it is nice to open out a map and see the whole picture. As I am an early riser (compared to my other half!!), while away I will plan our days walking that morning with the map opened out in front of me while enjoying a nice cup of coffee!!!! Quote Link to comment
+NickandAliandEliza Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 Thanks for all the help. Regarding Memory Map, it is of no help to me as I have an etrex with no immediate intention of upgrading to anything else. Also don't own any type of PDA or other windows mobile type device. I have ordered an Active map. Thanks Reddeeps. I also think it is nice to open out a map and see the whole picture. As I am an early riser (compared to my other half!!), while away I will plan our days walking that morning with the map opened out in front of me while enjoying a nice cup of coffee!!!! Why do you think MM is of no use to you? I started off with a yellow etrex, but also had Memory Map. Just imagine still being able to see the whole picture, but then being able to create routes and waypoints by clicking a few buttons. The routes then magically being transferred to your GPS. You'll also be able to print off the bits of map you need with notes and routes and anything else you may need. Buy a cheap laminator and you'll have your Active Map - but custom made. Quote Link to comment
+reddeeps Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 But surely you can do that via the link I provided for wheres the path above, without spending on memory map. (although I do use gsak) Quote Link to comment
+The Blorenges Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 But surely you can do that via the link I provided for wheres the path above, without spending on memory map. (although I do use gsak) The answer would seem to be yes you can and it works quite well. But there is the problem that this site shares with others that use the data from the OS 'live'..... and this was only after a few clicks and upload of a GPX file! Chris (MrB) Quote Link to comment
WPMD Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 Bing.com has OS maps you can print out. We use it all the time Quote Link to comment
+Guanajuato Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 Give Trekbuddy combined with Mobile Atlas Creator (google will get you the web addressed) a try. It'll work on pretty much any phone. You need GPS (Internal or bluetooth) for the navigation side, but it gives you the cache details and hint plus pretty much any maps you might want with a little fiddling. Not great for actually finding the caches, but give you OS Maps and can overlay caches on it. Quote Link to comment
+Fianccetto Posted March 17, 2010 Share Posted March 17, 2010 My Active Explorer maps arrived today. Really please with them. Certainly worth it,even if you don't plan to use them out in the rain as they will last much longer than the unprotected paper ones. Quote Link to comment
+The Duckers Posted March 18, 2010 Author Share Posted March 18, 2010 without spending on memory map That also has a bearing on it..... Quote Link to comment
+reddeeps Posted March 18, 2010 Share Posted March 18, 2010 Oh dear MrB, sorry that happened, I must have been lucky as not seen that before, although it can be tempermental at uploading sometimes. Some caches it just wont accept and i get a file too large message, but its normally only caused by one cache, so it can be time consuming finding which one it is. But now you have warned me I will make sure I use it early in the morning or well in advance of when I need the map. I'm just wierd maybe as I still buy the os map, but dont like writing on them, hence why I like just putting the points on one I print off (and then laminate lol) so I can use it as we walk. But like the idea of just having the proper os map as well. Its a map thing, I must have a bit of a fetish about them. Quote Link to comment
+agentmancuso Posted March 18, 2010 Share Posted March 18, 2010 But like the idea of just having the proper os map as well. Its a map thing, I must have a bit of a fetish about them. Quite right, perfectly healthy. I have a full set of 1:50Ks Quote Link to comment
+NickandAliandEliza Posted March 19, 2010 Share Posted March 19, 2010 But surely you can do that via the link I provided for wheres the path above, without spending on memory map. (although I do use gsak) Just had a better look at the link you provided..........I'm impressed. It lacks quite a bit that MM has, but you can't complain with the difference in price between the two! Quote Link to comment
+The Blorenges Posted March 19, 2010 Share Posted March 19, 2010 But like the idea of just having the proper os map as well. Its a map thing, I must have a bit of a fetish about them. Quite right, perfectly healthy. I have a full set of 1:50Ks Yup, I spend hours sometimes just navigating round Memory Map... there is something about maps!! So, where is that 1km square on the 1:50K maps which is white - nothing in it, no features or anything? Chris (MrB) Quote Link to comment
Team Noodles Posted March 19, 2010 Share Posted March 19, 2010 (edited) memory map is just divine, nothing like being able to plot your way in/through in 'foreign' territory ahead of the day. (or just in a dream like state, for 'the future at some point in time' kinda thing) Edited March 19, 2010 by Ryuchan Quote Link to comment
+DesG Posted March 20, 2010 Share Posted March 20, 2010 (edited) So, where is that 1km square on the 1:50K maps which is white - nothing in it, no features or anything? Chris (MrB) It's grid reference SE8322 and there used to be a cache there called "The most boring cache in Britain!" GCMV4N Edited March 20, 2010 by snerdbe Quote Link to comment
+The Blorenges Posted March 20, 2010 Share Posted March 20, 2010 SE8322 has a pylon line running through the SW corner so its not empty Chris Quote Link to comment
+The Blorenges Posted March 20, 2010 Share Posted March 20, 2010 So, where is that 1km square on the 1:50K maps which is white - nothing in it, no features or anything? Chris (MrB) It's grid reference SE8322 and there used to be a cache there called "The most boring cache in Britain!" GCMV4N What a pity that cache has been archived. It was a worthwhile spot, IMO... Come on cachers of the NE, raise the profile of this boring spot to "not quite so boring" once more - Put a cache back there again! MrsB Quote Link to comment
+DesG Posted March 20, 2010 Share Posted March 20, 2010 What a pity that cache has been archived. It was a worthwhile spot, IMO... Come on cachers of the NE, raise the profile of this boring spot to "not quite so boring" once more - Put a cache back there again! MrsB Hear! Hear! Quote Link to comment
+*mouse* Posted March 20, 2010 Share Posted March 20, 2010 Love maps! Got the discover series on the Oregon which are great and cover us for 95% of the time. In the past I've also printed maps off MM and laminated them double sided into smallish squares so they don't get soggy on the trail. Have the advangtage that they can be blown up bigger than paper maps and also can be reused. I don't buy OS paper maps so much any more although we do have a collection of our favourite spots although I think the active maps are a great idea if you intend to use a map a lot. I'm in the process of moving office at work and one of the first thinks I arranged for the office wall was perspex covered floor to ceiling OS map of the area we cover. I could stare maps for hours - I am that sad!! Quote Link to comment
GerritS Posted March 20, 2010 Share Posted March 20, 2010 We have quite a few OS Explorer maps for various areas around the country and find them quite invaluable. We need a new one for our forthcoming break in the Forest of Dean as our existing one is quite battered and bruised. Would anyone recommend the Active map against the normal paper one? Battered and bruised means, used and abused ... This is a great thing means you have been out having fun My First new Forest map was a paper one, lasted 1 year my second was a waterproof one still going strong after several years. If I am visiting an area more than once I buy water proof if its more a one off I buy paper... I have a box of maps that I try and keep battered and abused I now have an Oregon great for maps, just I now tend to down load and not buy paper maps... Quote Link to comment
+smstext Posted March 21, 2010 Share Posted March 21, 2010 what do you use for downloading maps? im currently waiting to see what happens on this free maps thing the governement is trying to sort out to see if then the garmin os maps drop in price. Quote Link to comment
Edgemaster Posted March 24, 2010 Share Posted March 24, 2010 A completely free release of the OS maps will ruin the OS, and thus the maps! Quote Link to comment
+Jonovich Posted March 25, 2010 Share Posted March 25, 2010 Love maps! Got the discover series on the Oregon which are great and cover us for 95% of the time. In the past I've also printed maps off MM and laminated them double sided into smallish squares so they don't get soggy on the trail. Have the advangtage that they can be blown up bigger than paper maps and also can be reused. I don't buy OS paper maps so much any more although we do have a collection of our favourite spots although I think the active maps are a great idea if you intend to use a map a lot. I'm in the process of moving office at work and one of the first thinks I arranged for the office wall was perspex covered floor to ceiling OS map of the area we cover. I could stare maps for hours - I am that sad!! Hmm... OS Wallpaper... You could be onto something here! Not sure the other half would approve though Jon Quote Link to comment
+rob.marsh Posted March 25, 2010 Share Posted March 25, 2010 I have to say, as a Scout Leader (Explorer Section) and having come up through the movement since i was 6, I find the idea of electronic mapping great, but you won't catch me out on a hike withough my OS explorer map in its case, and my silva compass round my neck. Caching I'll have a GPS with OSM on it, but my main navigation will be done with the OS map. How else can you take reasonable long distance bearings with only a few inches of screen? Yep the GPS can do it, but batteries die and your shot. I use MM, mainly for planning competition hikes within scouting. Its great for plotting routes etc, and sending out prints of the locations of each checkpoint etc etc. Printing out the smaller areas and laminating them is great. That said, you can't beat a map in a map case. I have tried the laminate versions, and personally hate them. You can't fold them as well, and when you do fold them without following the premade folds I found the laminate would crease. Not only that, as earlier mentioned, a map case is far cheaper than buying a set of the laminated maps! Each to thier own though, we all have our ways of doing things. Quote Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.