BUG: Not all reviews are shown

[+Gill & Tony]

My adventure "Five Beaches" has received 23 reviews.  I know this from looking at the source code for the reviews display page, where it says var reviews = {"totalCount":23,

 

When I display the reviews page it only shows 20 reviews (two pages at 10 per page).  The missing ones are the last 3 in the list (or actually, the first three chronologically).

 

EDIT:  "One Track for All" has 53 reviews and only 5 pages are shown.

Edited April 20, 2023 by Gill & Tony

[+Max and 99]

I realize you're talking about a different source but I can see all 23 reviews for the Five Beaches adventure lab. 

Edited April 20, 2023 by Max and 99

[+Gill & Tony]

I think it is a bug in the display from https://labs.geocaching.com/builder/adventures 

 

Other sources may show all the reviews.

[Oceansazul]

We are taking a look. Thank you for the report. 

[+Gill & Tony]

2 hours ago, Oceansazul said:

We are taking a look. Thank you for the report. 

While you are looking at this, it would be nice to have an option to change the number of reviews on a page.  At the moment it is 10 and I don't think it can be changed.

 

Thanks

 

Tony

[Oceansazul]

@Gill & Tony Thank you for the feedback. I have a few follow-up questions, if you are willing to share. I dont know that we will be able to implement a selector for the number of reviews on the page but, we may be able to increase the number of reviews on the page. I am curious to understand how many reviews you would want to see at a time? Does that amount change based on certain circumstances or do you just want more to load at once, all the time? Thanks for any feedback you are willing to share. 

[+Gill & Tony]

5 hours ago, Oceansazul said:

@Gill & Tony Thank you for the feedback. I have a few follow-up questions, if you are willing to share. I dont know that we will be able to implement a selector for the number of reviews on the page but, we may be able to increase the number of reviews on the page. I am curious to understand how many reviews you would want to see at a time? Does that amount change based on certain circumstances or do you just want more to load at once, all the time? Thanks for any feedback you are willing to share. 

To be honest, that was just a nice-to-have feature and if it will be tricky to implement, then I'll be happy to stick with 10 per page.

 

There is one feature I would really like to see:  Include in the review list everyone who has completed the adventure, even those who didn't leave a review.  Just name and date and a blank review would be great.

 

I keep all my hides, including adventure stages, in a GSAK database and I create found logs for each lab cache for each review.  (I do not scrape the page, rather I manually copy the source code from the page and analyse that in a macro).  Having "Found It" logs for everyone who found it would be a true reflection of the history of the adventure.

[Oceansazul]

@Gill & Tony Thank you for your feedback and for that detail, we will take it into consideration. 

[+lee737]

10 hours ago, Gill & Tony said:

There is one feature I would really like to see:  Include in the review list everyone who has completed the adventure, even those who didn't leave a review.  Just name and date and a blank review would be great.

I'd like to see that too....

[+ari54321]

Our engineers fixed the issue earlier this week, and it appears all reviews are displaying as expected. Please let us know if you continue to experience any issues!
 

[+Gill & Tony]

2 hours ago, ari54321 said:

Our engineers fixed the issue earlier this week, and it appears all reviews are displaying as expected. Please let us know if you continue to experience any issues!
 

Thanks for that info and to the engineers for fixing it.  Yes, all seems in order now.

 

No chance of getting the completions without reviews listed?