I have an idea for a coin design that I hope to finalize in the coming months and mint possibly just after the new year. I'm not a big time coin enthusiast, really just starting to pick up a few geocoins. So I'd like to pick a few brains if I could to find out what the community likes to see.
The coin would be bronze or copper, likely with an antique finish, 3D and round (rather "coinish", point of fact). I don't want to give away other details of the design, so please don't ask.
Is there a preference in size, say 1.5" vs 1.75"? I understand sometimes design/art drives size, but other than that, does size matter?
Is it preferable to have the coin trackable? Granted, I have less than 200 finds, but I've never seen a coin in the wild, and it seems they're collected more than passed.
Would it be preferable to have a coin serialized; to be able to know you have "coin number 25?"
I assume the fewer coins minted, the more desirable they become. If this were a design I wanted to use over again, would having a limited run with the year minted on the coin maintain that "rareness?" ("I have a 2008 USN-Ret coin, only 100 minted!") That way, perhaps another year could be minted with little change, yet still be considered a limited run and maintain that collectability/desirability.
TIA for your opinions/suggestions.