I have been using an eTrex for a little over a year now. Due to all of the high recommendations from the list for the SportTrakPro, I decided to take advantage of Costco’s great price of $189.99 after rebate.
Today, I went out to try out the SportTrakPro on a cache that I had recently found with my eTrex. I admit that the area is hard to navigate because of tree cover, but the SportTrakPro kept pointing me in the wrong direction. As I assumed that the GPS was defective, I rushed back to Costco to exchange it. I tried the same route this time with my eTrex in one hand and the new SportTrakPro in the other hand. The eTrex led me directly to the cache and the SportTrakPro again pointed in the wrong direction.
After that, I did some rather thorough testing to compare my old eTrex and the SportTrakPro by marking different landmarks in the open and in the trees. I then tried to navigate back to the marked points. The eTrex was far more accurate, in my testing, than the SportTrakPro. If some of the points that I marked would have been caches, I wouldn’t have found them with the SportTrakPro, but I would have with the eTrex.
This makes me wonder if the batch of SportTrakPro’s that Costco got were defective, or if the SportTrakPro’s doesn’t work in Oregon, or what. I can’t believe that everyone on this list that has been recommending the SportTrakPro can be wrong. I will be returning my second SportTrakPro tomorrow and will stick with my eTrex, for now. My wife was encouraging me to get a new GPS as I am hooked on geocaching. But I told her that, based on my experiences, I wouldn’t use the SportTrakPro if it was given to me. I was looking for more accuracy, not less.