No, I don't want to ruin it for those that honestly solve the puzzle, I just want to prevent those that take shortcuts from getting a find that they haven't earned.
I understand what you're saying, but I want to create a fun adventure that's going to be a real accomplishment for anybody that completes it, and not just be another find for cachers to notch on their belt on the way to their next 1000 milestone.
TopShelfRob,
You could most definitely create a unique solution to your puzzle problem . For example, a one-time-use code that unlocks your cache is revealed at the completion of your puzzle. This code could change everytime your cache was opened using it, requiring your cacher to solve the puzzle to find (and sign the log) of the cache. Now, lets say their friends tell them *how to* solve the puzzle, and they get their own code to use. Well, you could have also have a one-time-use puzzle that morphs as people solve it, all with the same relative difficulty. As I type this, I see how awesome this could be, now where to hide it is the question .
-LunaticSpawn