As a newbie with only 27 finds, I have gone through many phases of "What Geocaching Means To Me." First it was about the hunt, then the trade, then the TB, then the Jeep TB, then the hike. Now it's all about the enjoyment of it all. I love it! Even if I walk away from a cache without a cool object in hand, I always take something away with me...a photo, a memory, a feeling of satisfaction.
With that said...
After reading how passionate others are about what is left in caches I started feeling guilty about the batman, the jawharp, the Tomb Raider game and the jeweled headband my family and I have left in some of the caches we have visited. I thought they were pretty good at the time but gosh with all the complaints I started feeling pretty crummy. So I revisited the cache sites online and much to my surprise all of those "gifts" have been retrieved by other geocachers! Hmmm. Very interesting! I guess someone liked them. On the same note, another item I thought was cool, has been sitting in a cache for quite some time.
So I guess maybe the value of a trade item is determined not by who leaves it but by who takes it. Maybe it's a good idea for everyone who thinks they are "trading up" to go back and check on the items they have left behind. Have you made someone happy? Or is your "trade up" item collecting dust? Then adjust your swag accordingly.
Just a thought.