Hey all,
I'm brand new to caching (like four or five days since I found the Geocaching website) I haven't read all of the posts of this thread and others that have dealt with this situation. But as a current "county mountie", I decided to throw my two cents in. And let me say from the start, I don't claim to be an expert on what happened and am not saying that anything that anyone else has posted is wrong or incorrect. This is just my opinion on what i have read and my knowledge of the law. So, if you don't agree with what I'm about to say, that's OK. It's just a difference of opinion.
Based on what I have read, I think that the officers detained Lemur and, as Lemur has said, they had a right to do so. Technically, Lemur had violated the law. He was trespassing in an area where he shouldn't have been. As to how well it was posted, that might have been an issue for the lawyers to argue if the situation had ended up in court. I know from my 20+ yrs in law enforcement, I have come across people who (by the letter of the law) were trespassing. But after speaking with them and using my cognative reasoning device (aka, my brain) I realized that these people were not criminals (by the spirit of the law).
Lemur had pointed out that the officers did what was necessary and reasonable in this incident to determine what he was up to. It's unfortunate that he had to spend several hours with them in order to clear it up but sometimes the wheels (and brains) of justice move slow. The locals did what they needed to do to make sure Lemur was who he said he was and he was doing what he said he was doing. The the Feds came in and they wanted to make sure everything was on the up and up by their standards. Put yourself in their positions. Would you like to be the officer or agent who let a terrorist go after sort up checking on his story, only to have him hijack a plane or some other act that killed innocents? And then the media finds out?
My hat is off to Lemur for how he handled the situation. He acted responsibly and with tact, even when he got some badge heavy jerk who wanted to try his "bad cop" routine out. Just because some officer is a jerk (yes, there are some of them out there), doesn't mean you should return in kind. And you will gain a lot of respect from the other officers there who know the one guy is a jerk and probably don't like him anyway.
Anyway, I've rambled on enough. Lemur, If you still have the Travel bug that needs to make it to Disneyland, I'm taking my daughter there within the next month. E-mail me if you want me to escort him there.
Dogboy40