Seeing as I have found it difficult to edit my previous post, I will state most of how I truly feel, and where I'm coming from, here:
Most of my caches are on trails and hills, twenty miles from my home, overlooking a beautiful lake in Southern Oregon.
I hid them, so that others may enjoy the views of nature, as I have for all 14 years of my life.
This game is a treasure hunt, right? You will always have a goal, no matter what. Some do it for the numbers, for others, just getting outdoors or to exercise.
I cache for fun, and for entertainment... for the experience.
Extra requirements are for the experience.
They make caching fun, and offer a detour from the tiresome "lamp-skirt" hides
You make them optional, the population of ALR caches will dwindle. There won't be much of a reason to write them, because there won't be much of a reason for others to complete them.
I will oppose this new "Guideline" for as long as it is labelled as such.
The only reason that I am going to rewrite my caches, is that odds are they would be archived, and I would be banned from the site.