In my first cache I loaded up a 1G USB stick with Ubuntu, my next few I did $5 gas cards. So now I found this video on YouTube how to make lock picks from carbon-steel hack saw blades and I'm thinking this would be a unique FTF prize. Learning to pick is fun (nearly addictive!) & educational, the technology in a tumbler lock is like 4000 years old so it's hardly forbidden knowledge or anything. Plus it means never again having to take a hammer to a file cabinet or desk drawer when you've lost the key! The set includes (from top to bottom) a tension wrench, hook pick, sawtooth rake & a random rake. About $5 in materials and ~45 minutes to grind them.
I should note that in Iowa where I live pick sets are perfectly legal as long as you don't possess them with -the intent to commit a crime- just like a hammer or a crowbar. (Which would include picking a locked cache when you can't find the key!!)
Geocachers are curious by their nature and I think this is something they would genuinely enjoy.