Let me preface my opinion by stating that I haven't been caching for too long, I have never placed a cache, I'm not in your area, so I probably won't get to participate in finding your cache, and I don't know what types of caches the folks in your local community prefer, or even what the terrain and geography is like there.
The first cache I went looking for was the one closest to home, so I'm guessing you live pretty close to your first find, too. I looked at the list other nearby caches in that area, and the vast majority of them are 1/1. Now, I love caching and I'll go looking for those 1/1's all day, but your area seems like it's ready for something different..! I think you should go for it and place the 5/3 right off the bat.
You can always set the cachers' expectations in your description of the cache. Make sure they know what they're in for--Tell them that it will be a long and arduous path upon which their mental capacity will be taxed to the very limit... Tell them that when they look down and see only one set of footprints, it's because Jesus was carrying them to the third stage of the cache. Tell them that the rivers will run red with the blood of those who failed to find the cache, and that the wailing of their women is still heard across the land. Not only will they know exactly what they're getting into, but they'll appreciate it even more when they actually find the cache!
And they won't be the only ones with a feeling of triumph and success in their hearts. YOU will feel it, too. You'll be able to be proud of the fact that you designed a really solid, challenging cache, and you'll be proud of the fellow cachers who manage to find it.
There are plenty of 2's and 3's in your area, my friend... Go forth, and place a 5/3 cache so totally cool, that people will come in from out of state to hunt for it. (insert swell of patriotic music here)A cache that will make us all proud. A cache that will bring us together. A cache that will change the very face of our sport! You have the tools! You have the knowledge! You have the support and adoration of your fellow cachers! YOU WILL NOT FAIL!
[This message was edited by Jinkeez on April 16, 2002 at 10:13 AM.]