The evolution of geocaching, more or less..
1. GPS Sats - SA turned off
2. Cache hunts begin on Sat Nav newsgroup
3. Geocaching.com website opens
4. Ammoboxes & Tupperware become standard items
5. Hitchhikers appear in caches
6. Micro-caches used, especially in urban areas
7. Multi-caches appear
8. Virtual caches appear
9. Letterbox-Hybrid caches appear
9. GC.com replaces player-owned Hitchhikers with GC.com-owned Travel Bugs
10. Locationless caches appear
11. What will come next?
The point is that it's healthy for geocaching to grow and change. It's pointless to try to "stop" it's growth or to stop the creativity and ingenuity of geocaches to invent new concepts for the game. It's hard to believe that some people are already falling into the "NO CHANGE!" mindset. Have we grown to the point of having conservatives and progressives? Will we soon have political parties within this sport?
Give up this silly argument over what IS or IS NOT geocaching, and keep on inventing new concepts for the game. The ideas that don't work will fall away, or never get off the ground. The simple fact that so many people enjoy virtual and locationless caches is proof that they work just fine. You decide for yourself which caches to play. Please don't try to tell me which caches I can play.
Is the argument really just about who scores more "finds", with some players being so competitive that they can't enjoy a silly sport like geocaching without having their Type-A personalities get in the way?
If that's it, then ask GC.com to establish a separate "Find" category for locationless caches, to give more definition to the scores. Or not. Is it really so important how many "real" vs. locationless caches you've found? I play all kinds of caches. If someone cares to know exactly what I found, they can check the list on my profile page. Does anyone really bother doing that? I could care less what other players find, and am just happy to know they're enjoying the sport. If some of them have 400, 600 or 1,000 finds after their name, so be it. Are they lieing? Were they all locationless caches? Does anyone really care?
We need to encourage the sport to grow and evolve. Setting to many limits and making lots of rules will eventually backfire, and hurt us all. Keep your mind open, and go with the flow. Don't become the Geocaching Gestapo. Trying for total control didn't work then, and it won't work now.
Anton, N2RUD
Anton - N2RUD
Syracuse, NY