On the way to hiding a cache the other day, my family stopped for lunch at Burger King. The girls got an alien robot toy in their happy meals.
We filled the cache we placed with toys from the dollar store, and my girls wanted to put their new McToys in too. I was reluctant because of all of the negative publicity the McToys get on this forum. After much begging, I gave in.
A few days later I read the log from the first finder. What did his boy pick to trade ? You guessed it, the McToy.
My conclusion, McToys are OK as long as they are new with all the parts (still wrapped in plastic is best).