Moun10Bike Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 Okay, we appear to have settled on some choices for the design of the 2005 Washington State Geocoin in this thread. Now, let's put the ideas to a vote. Please select from one of the following choices and post a message to that effect here. Anyone is welcome to vote, but in the case of a tie or close race, we will consider the votes of Washingtonians and especially WSGA members first. Feel free to elaborate on your choice (for example, stating whether you want to combine one or more designs, use Mt. St. Helens' 1980 eruption or 2004 eruption, etc.), but please refrain from submitting new ideas for the design here. Leave those ideas for the original 2005 geocoin thread. If a new idea is proposed that people thinks should be added, I will update this message with the new selection and people will have the freedom to change their vote. Sound reasonable? Okay, the selections: 1) Mt. St. Helens 2) Columbia River 3) Washington Coast 4) Space Needle/Seattle Skyline 5) Grand Coulee Dam I'll give the voting 2 weeks and then will tally the votes here. Thanks!
Moun10Bike Posted February 7, 2005 Author Posted February 7, 2005 My choice: 1) Mt. St. Helens I would prefer to see the 1980 eruption.
+blazerfan Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 A vote from Oregon I vote 1) St. Helens Sure it's another mountain, but its a good one. I remember ash all the way down here when it erupted. I'd like to see a mock up of 1980 and 2004 to see which will be best.
+Bull Moose Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 1) St. Helens However the people with the talent in design want to do it.
+Belleterre Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 1) Mt. St. Helens 1980 eruption, because it's the 25th anniversary Then get away from mountains for a few years.
+Spencersb Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 (edited) I'll go with St Helens 1980 with an anniversary tie-in, too, just make it a color picture, the one that's just indented in the surface looks too much like a big tree growing out of the hole to me. But of course, I'll buy whatever is minted! Edited February 7, 2005 by Spencersb
+globalgirl Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 Well o.k. then it's unanimous (leastwise in the first 2 minutes of voiting) Ditto - Mdm. St. Helens it is! For the (wise, learned and uncannily logical) reasons cited earlier: 1. It's become an icon symbolizing WA state to all the world. 2. It's the 25th anniversary of the eruption (and thus - depicting it in another year would be far less timely. Indeed, choosing it for 2005 would make it an even greater collector's item) 3. Recent volcanic activity - noted by folks all over the world - only adds to the timeliness. 4. Arguably wet/dry side neutral I also agree w/ M10B that the 1980 eruption is far more impressive than the more recent pathetic dribble... And I also favor a bit of color, not purely embossed metal. Ideally just a band of green around the edge to compliment the "The Evergreen State" therein - just seems like that singular touch of color will make it "sing" and provide a good contrast to accent the embossed center. Oh and... seein' how you kindly asked for "elaboration" - im<decidedly far from>ho - puleeeeeese don't prostitute our proud WA state geocoin by slathering it with the ubiquitious quad-color (torquoise/yellow/green/peach) banner of gc.com. Surely nothing personal, and fine for avatars (incl. my own!) here in the Groundspeak forums, but... I dare say this is OUR coin after all, not a hatchling from a corporate business.
+Kealia Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 (Voting from California, but born in Spokane) Mt St Helens from 1980 with a commemorative 25 year note. I remember being young and living here in CA, but my grandfather sent us a package of ash once he dug his house out from underneath it.
MarcusArelius Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 I also vote for St. Helens. But we definately need to keep some of those idea's warm for future years. P.S. Moun10Bike didn't say anything about sock puppet votes but we probably don't want another "flawed" election now do we....
+Shop99er Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 Mt. St. Helens The Grey Version on the other thread.
+Wienerdog Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 (edited) Fair enough, Mt St Helens 1980. Maybe we can have something from the “other Washington” next year. Edited February 7, 2005 by Wienerdog
+Patudles Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 (edited) Mt. St. Helens 1980 version embossed style. Don't worry we've got lots of years left to quibble over the other designs. We could even add a stalk of wheat to the future designs beings Washington is #2 producer of wheat in the world. edit: spelling Edited February 7, 2005 by Patudles
+Stump Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 Maybe we can have something from the “other Washington” next year. Like the White House or Smithsonian? Seems redundant now but I vote for Mt. St. Helens. The Evergreen State doesn't seem right for a symbol of something that destroyed so many trees so suggest we change that. Don't have a preference for whether it's '80 or '04 eruptions, whatever looks nicest on a coin.
+GeoDiver/GeoGrammy Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 1980's Mt. St. Helens... Inscription could read: "ASHington - The EverGREYState"
+Wienerdog Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 Like the White House or Smithsonian? Whoops, I guess I misspoke on that one. On the other hand maybe that’s not to far out. The “other Washington” paid the cleanup bill.
Team Misguided Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 I have to say I prefer the Columbia River, but will buy what ever is minted.
+Allanon Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 Mt. St. Helens gets my vote. Which design will depend on the final two choices. To help that along, I did a very poor 'relief' version of the 1980 eruption and pasted it onto an existing Navdog design and posted it here for those interested.
+hydnsek Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 Mt Saint Helens 1980 with 25th anniversary notation it's a landslide....do we really need 2 weeks to decide?
+Cav Scout Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I vote St Helens... Any chance of getting Harry Trumans face on the coin to? He was quite a character before the eruption in 1980.
+k7-wave Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I also prefer Mt St. Helens, 1980 eruption, and 25th anniversary inscription.
+WeightMan Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 My preference would be 1) Columbia River, 2) Grand Coulee Dam If it is to be Mt. St. Helens, as it appears to be the choice, then I would prefer a 1980 view. I don't think Allanon's version does it justice though. I thnk something from the sequence shot from Mt. Adams would be more familiar to most people.
+Seth! Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 My Aunt Helen. She would look great on a coin. What? Oh. Nevermind. I think a billowing volcano would be good, too. - !
+Allanon Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I don't think Allanon's version does it justice though. Believe me, neither does Allanon... I was hoping to shame Navdog into doing up one through my pitiful effort.
+Patudles Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 Seems Mt. St. Helen is getting the votes my question is.... Would it be better in the silver color or a bronze or gold antique? Which would bring out the design best?
+Shop99er Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 Mrs. Shop99er here...do I count? The 1980 version of Mt. St. Helens in gray with the 4 color border is VERY nice. Can we pre-order now!! *smirk*
+Navdog Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I'm not voting, since I'm not a Washingtonian, although I do live a mile from the border and can see St. Helen's from my patio. I'd strongly consider using the 2004 photo of the mountain for several reasons: If you look at the 2004 coin, part of the uniqueness to it is the 3D effect created by the hiker in the foreground and the raised coin material in the back. Having just an image of raised coin material of the 1980 eruption is going to look pretty blah. There really needs to be something else in the image. The hiker adds a purpose to the coin that geocachers can identify with. And it also give that necessary depth of field. It also makes a statement about the use of a GPS today in and around the mountain. Does the other side of the coin really do enough to identify the coin as a geocoin? It really is just a tribute to gc.com Putting the 25th Anniversary text in the image helps balance the design. Washington is still the Evergreen State, and if you were to hike thorough the blast zone today, you would see how Mother Nature is quickly "greening up" the place. Just some things to consider.
+Shop99er Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I'm not voting, since I'm not a Washingtonian, although I do live a mile from the border and can see St. Helen's from my patio. Show-off
+The Navigatorz Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I vote for Mt. St. Columbia. Actually, I vote for the Mighty Columbia.
+Pepper Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 Well I'm feeling like a Texan (long term WA tourist) at this point because I really liked the the space needle coin, fun and colorful. If you can't beat um, join um. Mt St. Helens, either blast 80/04 with a very deep releif, color around the rim with mention of 25 yr anniversary. I'll buy what ever. Pepper
+Prying Pandora Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 Mt. St. Helens, of course! Don't have a preference for design particulars yet - would rather wait and see some choices created first.
+evergreenhiker! Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 My choice: 1) Mt. St. Helens I would prefer to see the 1980 eruption. Ditto...vote for St. Helens and '80 eruption.
+evergreenhiker! Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I vote St Helens... Any chance of getting Harry Trumans face on the coin to? He was quite a character before the eruption in 1980. I like that idea too, but would it be too expensive?
+Defender1 Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I'm with Pepper If you cant beat um join um, my first vote would be for the Columbia River, but my second would be St. Helens.
+MedicOne Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I shoveled enough of Mount St Helens out of my yard and off my roof - I've no fond memories of that event. My vote is for Columbia River or Washington Coast.
+slinger91 Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 2) Columbia River If it's to be St. Helens, Navdog's '04 design, no color.
+LittleBlue Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 1)My vote is for Mt. St. Helens. No real preference for which time period- I think color helps our coins stand out, tho. I still like The Evergreen State motto- and something about it being the 25th Anniversary.
Tenniskid Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I like the Space Needle one. My mom taught me, if all your friends jump off the cliff do you? Naw, seems like all like the MSH one, I like them all, but I'll buy either way. ~D
+kiltsurfer Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 said it before and I'll say it again. Mt. St. Helens It looks like a mudslide for the Mt. again.....
nolenator Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 Ah what the heck, I climbed the darn thing last year. Mt. St. Helens Peace, Nolenator
+Grandpa Rocks & Grouchy Gramma Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 I'm liking the Columbia River one. Born in the Tri Cities (Richland), graduated high school (RHS 71), US Army from Washington, served at Ft Lewis for two of my six years, graduated from Spokane Community College 1981. Pretty much a Washingtonian but lived across the river in Oregon since 1981. But second choice would be Saint Helens 1981. I was on the receiving end of the ash in Spokane while in college there.
+tolmaus Posted February 8, 2005 Posted February 8, 2005 (edited) Mount St. Helens Edited February 8, 2005 by tolmaus
Recommended Posts