Jump to content

Vulgar cache got approved

GPS-Hermit

By GPS-Hermit
in General geocaching topics

Followers 0

Recommended Posts

Ecylram

+Ecylram

Posted
Posted

http://coord.info/GC2JYD6

 

This cache just got published - I for one think it is very suggestive of a place where the owner had sex in high school. Do you agree or not and should it have been approved!

Vulgar...depends on your definition.

 

Inappropriate, I'd agree.

Chokecherry

+Chokecherry

Posted
Posted (edited)

It appears just from title alone it's somewhere the owner worked (as well as expounded on in the description). I didn't find it remotely vulgar.

 

Oh wait never mind. I read more closely. I'd go with inappropriate but not vulgar.

Edited by Chokecherry
knowschad

knowschad

Posted
Posted
http://coord.info/GC2JYD6

 

This cache just got published - I for one think it is very suggestive of a place where the owner had sex in high school. Do you agree or not and should it have been approved!

I don't see it as particularily vulger. Probably less so than your post. It doesn't even explicitly mention sex (unless it has been edited since you posted this).
GPS-Hermit

GPS-Hermit

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Would you have approved it! this is a family oriented game and I don't see a place for to celebrate what one did in this case as appropriate for a cache! Would you have approved it.

Edited by GPS-Hermit
zoltig

+zoltig

Posted
Posted

Would you have approved it! this is a family oriented game and I don't see a place for to celebrate what one did in this case as appropriate for a cache! Would you have approved it.

No approval made. Just reviewed. Ask the volunteer reviewer.

SeekerOfTheWay

+SeekerOfTheWay

Posted
Posted (edited)

Sex isn't vulgar. I don't find the cache page inappropriate In any case it's up to the parents to decide what the kids read. Keep them off that cache page if you find it vulgar.

 

Little kids won't even get the reference. Older kids may, and so what? I guess no harm if they already know!

 

I like caches with a personal meaning behind them!

Edited by SeekerOfTheWay
Chokecherry

+Chokecherry

Posted
Posted

Since I use "doing the deed" to describe any number of activities I do through out the day I wouldn't expect any children around me to see that title and think anything obscene about it. And realistically any child that reads the description would be hard pressed to identify anything obscene from that.

 

There is no explicit description of sex in that cache page. As a wink and nod adult to adult joke it's amusing to me. And completely over a child's head. I hardly see it as a celebration either. Someone had sex and made a silly little joke out of it. It's not liek they're sending up flares or posting a movie of what happened on the website. Or sending people to a container full of pictures of what happened in the parking spot.

 

I'm not a reviewer but I would bet I would have published the cache.

MisterEFQ

MisterEFQ

Posted
Posted

You know I asked a question around halloween about placing a cache about a myth about a family that was murdered and hung from meat hooks. I figured I would get the "this is a family game" comments.

 

I got quite the opposite and was introduced to plenty of caches that revolved around murders and people getting their heads cut off. This thread kinda makes me laugh after I read some of those cache pages.

 

Nothing on that page actually mentions what the deed is. Its just implied.

 

I think you are being a bit uptight.

Chokecherry

+Chokecherry

Posted
Posted

You know I asked a question around halloween about placing a cache about a myth about a family that was murdered and hung from meat hooks. I figured I would get the "this is a family game" comments.

 

I got quite the opposite and was introduced to plenty of caches that revolved around murders and people getting their heads cut off. This thread kinda makes me laugh after I read some of those cache pages.

 

Nothing on that page actually mentions what the deed is. Its just implied.

 

I think you are being a bit uptight.

 

I totally appreciated that thread. Found a cache to do on my next vacation.

 

Anyhow, there are historic caches the commemorate sites of death or burial areas all over the place. If a cache that gives a vague (and it is vague) reference to sex is vulgar those other caches certainly would be vulgar to in my eyes (if not more vulgar).

 

Not to mention all the caches in places now where people actively have sex that you risk walking in on.

GPS-Hermit

GPS-Hermit

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I approve much less of using the cache page as a forum to air your grievances. Either contact a reviewer or don't, but leave the cache page alone.

 

reviewer has been contacted - we will see what is said - I really want to know what the limits are in Geo-caching

 

This is a adult theme and we are not allowed adult material in the caches, along with weapons, drugs or knives. IN keeping with that we do have our limits on what should be done and this one is way over the limit.

zoltig

+zoltig

Posted
Posted

I approve much less of using the cache page as a forum to air your grievances. Either contact a reviewer or don't, but leave the cache page alone.

 

reviewer has been contacted - we will see what is said - I really want to know what the limits are in Geo-caching

 

This is a adult theme and we are not allowed adult material in the caches, along with weapons, drugs or knives. IN keeping with that we do have our limits on what should be done and this one is way over the limit.

Yeah bad form to post to a cache page like that.

GPS-Hermit

GPS-Hermit

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Gee, just how much of a hermit are you?? I think this is funny!

Hermits get away from everyone else when they do what they do and keep it private!

 

Some CO's are not very private! Even when they should be!

GPS-Hermit

GPS-Hermit

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Would you have approved it! this is a family oriented game and I don't see a place for to celebrate what one did in this case as appropriate for a cache! Would you have approved it.

 

Again I am asking - if you were an approver/reviewer etc would you have approved this cache!

Edited by GPS-Hermit
Harry Dolphin

+Harry Dolphin

Posted
Posted

Vulgar and inappropriate? Definitely. But, unfortunately, that's the way Geocaching is heading. Sad. I found that out with the cache outside the porn shop. "Slow Poke". "Adults will understand the title when they see the location." Puerile humor. Nope. No guidelines violation. Sad to say. Oh, well.

How's this for 'inappropriate'? Members Only Cache

I think it's the fora that are 'family friendly', not the caches. (So stop talking about sex!)

Gorak

+Gorak

Posted
Posted

I think some people try too hard to be offended... GreySurprized.gif

 

If you can be offended by that then you must be apoplectic by what you see on the Disney Channel! GreyLaughingAnim.gif

 

GreySquint.gif

Space*Cadet

Space*Cadet

Posted
Posted (edited)

http://coord.info/GC2JYD6

 

This cache just got published - I for one think it is very suggestive of a place where the owner had sex in high school. Do you agree or not and should it have been approved!

 

I would agree that it is very inappropriate for Geocaching, and I sent a little note to the reviewer, in case they probably did not read the description, asking if they would reconsider publishing it, and request the CO to change the description.

 

It would definately be an uncomfortable situtation for a family with young children, to discover it!

Just my 2cents :laughing:

 

Here is a cache that I don't particularly care for either! GC201H4 It's on the inappropriate side also!

Edited by huntress123
GPS-Hermit

GPS-Hermit

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Stuff like that can turn you into an Innkeeper later on in life.

 

If a hotel does not even rate one star will you take your family there!

Edited by GPS-Hermit
GPS-Hermit

GPS-Hermit

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Here is a part of a log GPS Hermit wrote for Fisherman's Cache:

 

Co-ordinates were "Dead on Balls Accurate"

 

I guess family friendly doesn't apply to his logs. :laughing:

 

That is an engineering term involving ball bearing causing measurements to be perfectly accurate!

"my cousin vinny" not a vulger term!

Edited by GPS-Hermit
bflentje

+bflentje

Posted
Posted (edited)

I think some people try too hard to be offended... GreySurprized.gif

 

If you can be offended by that then you must be apoplectic by what you see on the Disney Channel! GreyLaughingAnim.gif

 

GreySquint.gif

 

OMG, nothing could be closer to the truth. I say to the OP, get a grip.

Edited by bflentje
Space*Cadet

Space*Cadet

Posted
Posted (edited)

Here is a part of a log GPS Hermit wrote for Fisherman's Cache:

 

Co-ordinates were "Dead on Balls Accurate"

 

I guess family friendly doesn't apply to his logs. :laughing:

 

:laughing: What great line by Marisa Tomei from"My Cousin Vinny!"

Edited by huntress123
wimseyguy

+wimseyguy

Posted
Posted

It barely crosses from G to PG on my vulgarometer.

 

Can I say barely in here?

 

Someone where I work got questioned by the IT police shortly after they added new monitoring software for looking up a chicken breast recipe. :D

Gorak

+Gorak

Posted
Posted

Here is a part of a log GPS Hermit wrote for Fisherman's Cache:

 

Co-ordinates were "Dead on Balls Accurate"

 

I guess family friendly doesn't apply to his logs. :D

 

That is an engineering term involving ball bearing causing measurements to be perfectly accurate!

"my cousin vinny" not a vulger term!

Actually, according to several sources on the Internet, the expression DOBA became part of popular vernacular after first appearing in the movie, "My Cousin Vinny". Prior to that it was not an engineering term referring to accuracy of ball bearing measurements. But it got a lot of laughs in the movie!

 

Nice try, though! GreyWink.gif

 

GreySquint.gif

The Blorenges

+The Blorenges

Posted
Posted

Suggestive - yes

 

Vulgar - a bit (using the definition of "vulgar" as marked by lack of taste, culture, delicacy, manners, etc. )

 

However, there's nothing on that page that would be questionable for an innocent child to read.

 

(I'm more offended by the fact that the cache owner has been through high school and can't spell magical correctly :D )

 

Yes, I'd publish it... reluctantly... with a sigh.

 

MrsB

tozainamboku

+tozainamboku

Posted
Posted (edited)

I don't see anything in either the cache title or in the description that says the cache owner had sex in high school at this place. I supposed you could imagine that's what it means. But puritans do have a reputation for claiming a simple sentence says something beyond what is actually written. :D

Edited by tozainamboku
dfx

+dfx

Posted
Posted
(I'm more offended by the fact that the cache owner has been through high school and can't spell magical correctly :D )

you're really surprised by this, now that you know what she had been busy doing during HS? :D

DadOf6Furrballs

+DadOf6Furrballs

Posted
Posted (edited)

Vulgar? Na. Offensive? Na. Maybe a "bit" risque, but nothing to get into a hand-wringing episode about. But as always, just my own 2¢, for whatever you can buy with that these days.

 

-- edit... looks like the CO already caved and changed the title and description. Whatever. :D

Edited by DadOf6Furrballs
rawkhopper

+rawkhopper

Posted
Posted

I tend to think a badge of honor celebrating a deed of that nature is not vulgar but very low brow. Seems like a chick that would brag about how many notches she had on a bed post.

 

In the edit she seems to imply that she married the guy and he is a pastor. Well I do not personally know any pastors that would set up a memorial to misspent youth.

 

I understand not hiding from what happened but also think it is not something to brag about, especially since children of impressionable ages peruse this site.

The red-haired witch

+The red-haired witch

Posted
Posted

Again I am asking - if you were an approver/reviewer etc would you have approved this cache!

 

Of course I would have published it. Reviewers don't get to approve caches, they just publish them if they follow the guidelines. They can only refuse to publish if the guidelines are not followed.

 

As I can see nothing even remotely offensive in the cache page, I'm guessing that Groundspeak has used here the "if there is a complaint it is offensive and must therefore be edited" philosphy. It may makes sense in the client service business, but it sometimes means that something that is ok with 99.9% of people and not ok for 0.1% of people has to be changed.

 

Having seen the other caches brought up as "objectionable", I'd say some people here are a little too easily offended. Some jokes may be childish, but that is a far cry from saying that it means the cache will traumatize kids who may find it. As others have said, either they won't understand the joke or it won't bother them... unless their parents overreact, in which case the parents reaction may cause some negative effect. OK, I realise this cache is in the US, where some people are willing to argue in court that the sight of a breast on TV can traumatize youg children. So I guess I shouldn't be surprised to see that a few american cachers are very easy to offend (I said a few... not generalizing here).

 

And for those saying that such jokes are a modern scourge and screaming "oh, look where this world is going, doom, doom doom!", I'd suggest you better not research a 1982 song from April Wine or think about how many times a pussy was mentioned on "Are you being Served", a series now several decades old.

 

Actually, I'm now thinking about making a cache about my cat and calling it "Cute Pussy".

 

Would that be vulgar and inappropriate for families to seek? :D

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Followers 0
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...