Sextant Geocoin

[+AtwellFamily]

I have been working on this coin for a while now. Based on Celestial Navigation, Sextant and Positioning Circle. Using these 3 things sailors would calculate thier position on the earth, you could say this was an early form of the GPSr.

 

I was looking for some feedback and interest level.

1. Do you like the design? Feedback welcome.
   
2. Would you buy it?
   
3. Should I make both versions (round and cutout)?
   

The mold cost on both of these is quite high becuase of the 3D Sextant on each. To give you more detail. Looking to produce these in 1.75" for the round one and 1.5" for the cutout. The plating will be a variety but will be doing a number of mixed/duel plating choice.

 

Edited November 13, 2007 by Atwell Family

[+intolerable]

Trying to decide what coins to buy on payday and really wish both designs were available to order, as they'd be on my list. I do prefer the round design, but I usually prefer my coins to be coin like :-) That's not at all to say I wouldn't order both though.

[+mrjiffy]

A nice looking coin that I would likely buy at least a couple of. I like the traditionally shaped coin, not as keen on the cutout although it still looks nice. If cost of the coin to me was kept to $10 or under, I would buy.

Thanks,

MRJIFFY

[+Mr.Explorer3]

A cut-out one for me please.

[+WWC-World's Worst Cacher]

shapped i would spend money on, round nope. In fact like the shaped a lot.

[+Landsharkz]

The Columbia Guide to Standard American English confirms that:

"A boat can be a good sailer because it sails well; but a good sailor is always “a person who is expert at sailing or helping to sail a boat” " .

 

We are sailors and our boat is a very good sailer! That being said... I like the shaped one .

[+AtlantaGal]

The shaped one makes for a much more interesting piece.

[+AtwellFamily]

The Columbia Guide to Standard American English confirms that:

"A boat can be a good sailer because it sails well; but a good sailor is always “a person who is expert at sailing or helping to sail a boat” " .

 

We are sailors and our boat is a very good sailer! That being said... I like the shaped one .

say what?

[+Droo]

Thumbs up for the shaped one.

[+3doxies]

I really like the round one best but both are beautiful. You really outdid yourself on this one! I would definitely buy.

[+High n Low]

I like them both but the back of the shaped, I'm not too excited about although I don't know how you would improve it. I would buy either version though.

[+avroair]

Looks cool. Although I believe a very similar design was used on the back of the GCC benchmark and another coin that I can't remember off the top of my head.

[+Accordiongal]

Like the overall idea. To me, the sextant is too busy, espically with the "arms" that stick out.

 

The inner detail with the geocaching @ is great.

 

Like both backs. I probably would pass.

 

Good luck with your project.

[+Traderdell]

I almost always prefer round coins but in this case I would go with the shaped one. Would purchase either or both though.

[Jake - Team A.I.]

Looks cool. Although I believe a very similar design was used on the back of the GCC benchmark and another coin that I can't remember off the top of my head.

 

You mean mine?

 

[+PaRacers]

I like the round one for sure...A LOT!! I'd like to see the constellations on the back too. Very nice - I'd buy a couple.

[+OshnDoc]

Looks cool. Although I believe a very similar design was used on the back of the GCC benchmark and another coin that I can't remember off the top of my head.

 

Team A.I. maybe?

 

edit:

I guess it would help to read to the end of the thread. Just saw Jakes post.

Edited November 14, 2007 by OshnDoc

[+stellarscapes]

I'd prefer the round coin.

 

However, I like the design on the front of the round coin, but I like the design on the back of the

shaped coin better (with the constellations on it).

 

Either way, I'd buy one.

[+Jackalgirl]

I was looking for some feedback and interest level.

[*]Do you like the design? Feedback welcome.

 

Yes!

 

Edited to add: I like both versions as they are. I like the geometry (sp?) on the round coin, and the constellations on the shaped one.

 

[*]Would you buy it?

 

YES

 

[*]Should I make both versions (round and cutout)?

 

If you had to stick with just one, I'd go with the cutout. If you think the demand supports both, do both. I'd buy at least one of each.

 

-- JG (a sailor)

Edited November 14, 2007 by Jackalgirl

[+Mystery Ink]

Like the shaped one, would probably buy a couple and use one for my boat keychain..

[danoshimano]

I'm trying to stick to personal coin issues, but I would definitely consider this coin as a special exception. My first choice would be round.

[+Nochipra]

I like both coins but I think I would like the shaped the best at this point. I like the constellations but I think they would be cool as glow in the dark. If you make a round coin I'd say go with the front of the round one and put the constellations in glow in dark on the back. Just my 2 cents worth:)

[+Frozen Buns]

Shape for me, Esp. if cost is kept to $10 inc. shipping

[Voyageurs60]

Like them both - slight edge to the cutout version

 

How can I be alerted that these coins are available?

 

Thank you,

voyageurs60 (Dan)

[+ShmilyNMe]

I like them both! Very nice designs...

[+GPX Navigators]

Geez Mike - tough choice.

 

Both are great. Would probably buy both too.

[+PJPeters]

Wow. That's all I've got to say!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Okay, that, and I'd buy a couple of each.

 

 

 

Wow, again!

[+wutzebear]

Unless they aren't available in the wrong moment (means i haven't bought to many coins in the last few days), i'd go for the shaped, perhaps the round ones too.

[+avroair]

Looks cool. Although I believe a very similar design was used on the back of the GCC benchmark and another coin that I can't remember off the top of my head.

 

You mean mine?

 

 

Yeah that's the one!

[+fairyhoney]

I, personally, am drawn to the shaped. But both coins are "cool"

[+fairyhoney]

I, personally, am drawn to the shaped. But both coins are "cool"

I admit that I am ignorant of this devise. But, will those things that stick out (they look fragile) break off?

[+avroair]

I, personally, am drawn to the shaped. But both coins are "cool"

I admit that I am ignorant of this devise. But, will those things that stick out (they look fragile) break off?

 

If ya fiddle with it they will...

[+Astro_D]

I really like the round design and would certainly be interested in buying a couple. Being astronomy enthusiasts ans sitting through a few celestial navigation classes the sextant is a great instrument.

[+fairyhoney]

I, personally, am drawn to the shaped. But both coins are "cool"

I admit that I am ignorant of this devise. But, will those things that stick out (they look fragile) break off?

 

If ya fiddle with it they will...

 

Oh, I guess, like the "paint sprayer" coin could be fragile

[+Shop99er]

Can I just go ahead and ask for one of each now, and avoid the rush?

[+Sunrayers]

I like them both and would be in for a couple of either (or both) I just confused myself!

[+Wij Drie]

I like them both and would probably buy both, if the costs are right and the shipping isn't to high.

 

tot cache,

team Wij Drie

[+wsgaskins]

I like 'em both. For this one, since it's not going to be a real, functional instrument, I'd say stick with the round one. For the back of the round one, maybe throw the stars on the back onto the 'celestial sphere' (proper locations, of course!) and add landmasses to the globe so that the calculated position is say, Denver Colorado.

[+Dolfy]

I like the look of the shaped one better. Really makes it unique.

[+AtwellFamily]

Like them both - slight edge to the cutout version

 

How can I be alerted that these coins are available?

 

Thank you,

voyageurs60 (Dan)

Go to my site in my sig and complete the contact form. I'll add you to my list of contacts.

[+AtwellFamily]

You guys are making this difficult. A 1/3 want round, 1/3 want cutout and 1/3 want both. And I'm sure everyone wants it for $10 or less. Oh and the stars should be in glow enamel. Did I miss anything?

 

1. Stars will be changed to glow and the lines will be removed.
   
2. I'll need to wait a bit until I can pay for the molds but will do both
   
3. Cost......They will be in the $11.50 range but that includes shipping in North America
   

That should be good for everyone. Thanks for the feedback. I'll make the changes and see how they look.

[+GEO*Trailblazer 1]

Just a quick question.

The coins look great,is there a way to make it a working sextant?

 

Wouldn't that be cool.

I know it would probably be more work though.

 

But like a spinning coin 2 pins should make it a workable piece.

[+backhiker]

Isn't fun how everyone has their own likes and dislikes! That's what makes the world (or is it stars) go round, and why you can't please everyone. Unless you make two coins

 

My vote would be for the round, I know it's traditional but I like the background around the sextant. JMHO

[+geo_taz]

I would definitely by the shaped one, but probably also the round one

[+Theseus]

Neat looking coin. I would go for the round one but not the shaped one - I think that puts me in the minority.

[+TazDevil091102]

Both are great looking and knowing me I'd buy both and be broke again.

[+Shop99er]

Just a quick question.

The coins look great,is there a way to make it a working sextant?

 

 

That would require some very small eyes....

[+mousekakat]

I like the shaped one!

[+Degai]

Wow! Yet, another awesome coin. I'd go for the round one.

[toponym]

I have been working on this coin for a while now. Based on Celestial Navigation, Sextant and Positioning Circle. Using these 3 things sailors would calculate thier position on the earth, you could say this was an early form of the GPSr.

 

I was looking for some feedback and interest level.

1. Do you like the design? Feedback welcome.
   
2. Would you buy it?
   
3. Should I make both versions (round and cutout)?
   

The mold cost on both of these is quite high becuase of the 3D Sextant on each. To give you more detail. Looking to produce these in 1.75" for the round one and 1.5" for the cutout. The plating will be a variety but will be doing a number of mixed/duel plating choice.

 

 

I like both designs and would buy a set.