I've only found 2 caches at this time...but I thought I would add my two sense. Personally...the thing that attracts me to Geo Caching is the experience of finding new places and the hunt...but I want the loot too.
I found my first cache today, I actually had my mom with me...she was more excited than I was. Well, the hike was amazing and I found a new place to go hiking. I was pumped when my GPS beeped and started looking for the cache...and I was just as excited when I finally found it.
When I finally opened it up and looked it...I was a little disappointed...a cache full of old toys, mctoys, and things I couldn't even identify. I was hoping to find something mildy useful...maybe a small flashlight or something.
I dunno...when I look for stuff to put into a cache...I look for stuff I would want...part of the whole geo caching experience is the "cache"...I wish everyone would just keep the quality of a cache up.