The Gauntlet cache in Lake Delton, Wi was done in fun and wasn't a controversey for many a cacher, myself included! It wasn't until some cry babies from Minnesota came to run the Gauntlet and were so embarrased that they got duped that the Gauntlet was exposed. I challenge you to email anyone of the cachers who found the Gauntlet and ask them if it was a bad cache.
As for the one who goes out of their way to out liars caches, I hope you stop geocaching really, really soon! You are obviously too wound up to just enjoy geocaching the way it's meant to be enjoyed and that is to go to a place that someone else wants to share. If you find the cache they have stashed and feel their rating/hide/write up wasn't to your liking, you'll complain. Seriously, nobody cares about you or your petty issues so stop geocaching. Maybe you'd be better off just standing in a checkout line at a super market arguing with the clerk because he/she won't double your 10 cents off coupon. That seems more up your alley!!