The "essence" of geocaching is FUN.
It is not always FUN to be constantly obligated to lookout and shop for new and interesting items, obsess about their trade value, lug a range of items through km/mi of off-road terrain, obsess some more at the find about value, then leaving with a vague unease that some sort of judgement will be passed over your choices?!
Getting way too complicated. At what point does caching stop being a sport/activity and becomes another bill to pay or even worse another form of bias?
I mean, do the math. Some peeps have logged over 3000 finds, even dollar store items would add up to a minimum of $3000, not to mention the time it would take actually find 3000 so-called quality trade items.
It is FUN to follow clues, get fresh air, meet peeps and look at all the goodies that reflect the unique personalities of previous visitors, without having to spend half of your valuable day engaged in enforced geoshopping.
If anyone has a compromise, it would be nice to hear about, but slamming us Newbie's, the TNLN peeps, as well as advocating Christmas-like shopping stress for every single cache detracts from the real benefits and intent of the game.
That's my 2 cents, now I'm broke! TN Left Opinion