I am very surprised at the attitudes and replys that have been posted on this thread and others, don't forget folks this IS a HOBBY, and different people have different interests.
I thought I was going by the guidelines, read the first paragraph, first sentance
"These are listing guidelines only"
"In order to ensure a prompt response when responding to an archival note please click on the Approver’s profile from the cache page and e-mail the approver through Geocaching.com."
I have e-mailed the approver, to appeal, but am STILL waiting a reply.
"Virtual Cache Maintenance Guidelines
Although the virtual cache is not something you physically maintain, you must maintain your virtual cache's web page and respond to inquiries and periodically check the location. You should also return to the Geocaching.com web site at least once a month to show you are still active"
This is no problem as I intend to visit the location at least twice a year to see what
more historic items they have discovered.
2. A virtual cache must be novel, of interest to other players, and have a special historic, community or geocaching quality that sets it apart from everyday subjects. Since the reward for a virtual cache is the location, the location should “WOW” the prospective finder.
I think the RENAGADE KNIGHT had it right in another thread,
Part of geocaching is about getting out and seeing what there is to see. Virtuals fit that.
Part of geoaching is about how to respond to not being able to find a box (because the NPS banned them). Virtuals fit that.
Part of geoaching is about fun. Virtuals fit that as much as a lame urban micro does.
Part of geoaching is using your GPS. Virtuals fit that.
Part of geocaching ls the "Log" and telling your adventure. Virtuals fit that.
Part of geoaching is about the numbers, yours, others, your next find, etc. Virtuals fit that.
Part of geoaching is about finding something hidden, or at least not so obviouse. Virtuals do fit that even if what you seek isn't a box.
Virtuals are accepted as caches, just as are webcams, multi caches and the like. That acceptace is all they need. Waypoint.org isn't virtual caching. Geocaching.com is. You tell me what the difference is and then you have answered your own question.
Sorry if I've stamped on peoples toes and rattled a few cages, but please don't forget it is ONLY a hobby, and what some folks think are next best thing to sliced bread, others are not at all interested in.