Not so much "smiley mentality" as risk/reward ratio. Go for five traditionals, if one has a problem the reward of four successes overrides the risk of putting in effort of five caches. Even if all five caches are a bust, at least one gets to potentially experience five interesting locations.
Yeah! That's exactly why I wanted to make each one able to stand on its own- they are all going to be worthwhile caches, thanks for pointing out the risk/reward factor, and for your previous comment about making it 3 trads and a mystery, that's what I suspected it would be.
And who doesn't love a smiley? Smileys are rad and if someone puts in the effort to find a cache then, gosh darnit, they should get a smiley. And if you hate micros, you get a baller ammo can at the end for putting up with them! Everyone's happy!
Anyways, I'm gonna think about this really hard and make sure I do the best job in in the true spirit of the game- getting outside and having fun and finding interesting things and places. I have a sweet vintage ammo can that I can't wait to place, it's my dad's from when we used to live in Canada and he's got some chronic health problems and can't really move around very well. He likes hearing my stories about caching and I wanted to make a really special cache with it so that I can tell him how people enjoyed finding it, he'll really get a kick out of it.
I'll post the cache on this thread when it gets published so y'all can check it out. Thanks to those of you that left positive, constructive feedback (like the paint pens, what a great idea!) I think I got it from here