I don't visit the forums often but this subject caught my eye. As one that started hiding an ammo box in the woods, then a film canister in suburbia then, evil hides in both woods and suburbia, this topic was of huge interest to me. The lame cache is in the eye of the beholder and the "place" they are in caching. Every Cacher goes through caching phases: finding, hiding, easy, hard, numbers, puzzles, multi's, difficulty stars, terrain stars, numbers in a day. Different cachers apply themselves to different levels of the game. What may be lame to one is a benefit or fun to another. Those that have found ten bus stop magnetic key holder micros think they are lame..the family first caching that finds their first bus stop micro is jumping up and down. It's all relative.
My Lame breakdown:
Not maintained
Crappy coords (take more than one reading PLEASE)
Crappy puzzle (there are actually many different solutions but the owner ignores it)
The possiblity of being yelled at by neighbors and/or the police are called
Trash and garbage around that could hurt someone or I don't want to explain to my kids (needles, broken glass, beer cans, porn, discarded red panties) Note: all of which may show up later without the cache owner knowing.
Misrepresented terrain rating (if you rate it a one star terrain that means no one has to fall out and crawl from their wheelchair)
Otherwise as a wise cacher once told me: to each his own. Everyone plays their own game and as long as played by the rules others shouldn't judge. That's not a rant, just what I have experienced myself as I used to rant. I don't now.