Ok so I've done some time in the Boy Scouts. Reading through these posts brings up some very good points about the MB program. The fact that the scouting movement is steeped in tradition is an understatement.. The fact that Geocaching is an easier form of orienteering is not going to bode well for creating a new badge. Within each MB there are elective requirements. Maybe this is an option that should be considered too. Kind of like putting a foot in the door. I know a couple of people who have worked trying to get a new badge into the system with many hurdles thrown at them by National. The problems with changing the existing badge requirements is they then need to reprint the books and it also makes the units pay for updated material which to a non-profit is like sqeezing blood from a stone. One thing I did get from those that have tried before is that starting with the units and working your way up with a well laid out program will gain needed support from the councils and will help when filing for the badge later.
Angry-Beaver (Eagle Scout Chester County Council PA, Camp Director, SM, UC,DC, etc....)