I am not going to provide the cache, it's not about whether or not he did something wrong, because he didn't do anything at all wrong in the cache listing. I was wrong in my original post, the CO never said anything about contacting him regarding the other caches, just to contact if anyone needed assistance. It's implied that there are other caches, but he doesn't mention them specifically. But what I want to know is, if the cache listing doesn't require you to go to another website to find the cache for this particular listing, but references other listing sites simply to mention the existence of the other caches, what's wrong with that (he doesn't do this, I just don't understand why he can't)? Going to the other listing sites is not required to find this particular cache, cachers are not being forced there to get the smiley. So, I guess he can't mention the existence of the other caches because "it contains the name of a business or commercial product"?