<Breaks out the paddles> "CLEAR!!!! I've got a pulse!!"
I'd like to put my 2 cents in on this.
I am new to the forums and relatively new to geocaching in general. I am up to 17 finds since June 12th. Yay!
If this topic had not been brought up again, I would have had to read who knows how many old topics before I found out about the Greasemonkey script GCVote. So even tho its been discussed to death by many, there are many others that can learn from this new thread.
Anyway, I now use the GCVote script and I went back and rated all my previous caches. I rate based on location (was it well thought out), creativity (was the description well thought out and what did I learn/see in searching for this cache and camo/hiding quality.
I think its a great idea and I hope it catches on.