Citing other examples may or may not be helpful. While I'm summarizing the Guidelines, they also say the following:
In this case, should the OP choose to provide details of his denied cache submission, I just took a look at the cache being cited as precedent. It is quite easily distinguishable. That is one reason for the quoted guideline -- no two caches are exactly alike.
I just thought an example or two might allow others to see the differences and likeness and allow for better feedback. Just trying to be helpful. I hope no toes are hurt.
The $heriff