Jump to content

SCP-173

Members
  • Posts

    1238
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by SCP-173

  1. While on a caching road trip this past week I traded for some wooden nickels I forgot I already had. I may as well trade them since I've got them now. I'll trade 'em for whatever you've got! Wow, I just said trade in every sentence of this post, lol.

     

    Fronts

    Frontscom.jpg

     

    Backs

    Backs.jpg

  2. I like coins that are round, antique finished and sequentially numbered. I almost always avoid shaped one unless they have a special meaning to me. Selling more than one finish publicly is a turn off to me, and being trackable is something I could take or leave, it doesn't matter to me either way.

  3. I think who it's from and why AND the fact that many others don't have a Lackey coin both go hand in hand for these coins. I bet that's what makes them special for most everyone who actually took initiative to travel to Seattle or met a Lackey to get one. There's a lot of things, all combined, that made them special. Selling them negates all that for me and I'm sure many others who are just not speaking up.

     

    There's nothing special about paying from a computer and getting something in the mail. You see people being upset because their coins aren't special if others can buy them, I see people who think it's a great idea because now they don't have to meet a Lackey or drive to Seattle which (I'm assuming) was Groundspeak's original intent way back in 2005 with the creation of the first Lackey coins.

  4. Making them available in unlimited quantities doesn't make them less special unless you think they are special because others don't have them.

    Yup, that's pretty much the concept behind making something limited right there. :unsure:

     

    Is a penny from today as special as an Indian head penny from the 1800's? Nope. Something you can get any amount of you want just isn't special.

  5. I think a lot of people would be placated if someone from Groundspeak would just take the time to explain why they chose to sell this one when all the others have been something you need to pretty much get by hand from a lackey.

     

    Of course I'm sure there's going to be people who say Groundspeak has no responsibility to explain the decision. :o

  6. I have been reading these posts and thought I would try to give a personal perspective from my limited experience. I do not belong to any clubs and untill recently was unaware of their existance. The following phrases really jumped to my attention.

     

    "not as impressive"

    "really boring"

    "having been done before"

    "uninteresting"

    "money making"

    Most of those are what I said. With regards to your coin and to clarify on my opinions, I'm sure that it's nicely designed, but no matter how nice it is I would probably be uninterested. Geocoin clubs usually make coins just for the sake of making them. Easter has nothing to do with the hobby, so for me I would find a geocoin that's just about Easter boring. Call me a purist I guess, I like coins that represent a caching team or individual, caching groups, events, certain caches and so on.

     

    Not everyone likes the same things though, this is just what turns me off to coin clubs.

     

    And to cover the coin clubs doing coins that have been done before part, there already is a geocoin shaped like a Peep.

  7. I think the map itself would be a neat idea. A set of 50 coins would be as unnecessary as the original 50 state quarters, though. It would be much more fun to fill it with existing state coins, but that leads to the problem of not all state coins being the same size and shape. I might be wrong but I can't see many people dropping nearly 400 dollars on something like this. You could just about make your own coin for that much.

  8. I hope no one minds if I hijack this thread just slightly since the question has been answered by a few and I kind of have questions regarding the same topic.

     

    I don't belong to a coin club but have given some thought to doing a "coin of the quarter" (1 coin design available every 4th month)(trackable/icon).

     

    Is there really reasonable interest in this kind of club and do people like surprise designs or a special metal/color combo not available to non coin club members?

     

    I've been thinking about it for some time but just haven't really made an effort to find out if it is worth doing or if it is something people really would be interested in.

     

    What is it that people like about the coin clubs? The surprise design or just a special version or combo of both?

    I think you have a good idea here. My honest opinion of the coin clubs now is that the vast majority of their coins are either really boring, have been done before or are just plain uninteresting. One every 4 months would give more time to design and work on a coin and would result in something of actual quality, especially if you had a hand in making it all happen. Quarterly seems more like you're trying to produce something cool, monthly is just a money maker in my opinion.

  9. Guess I speak for myself when I say it just doesn't mean as much unless you are handed one of these... and I so don't mean any offense by that.

    That's just me. Speaking out loud as I often do.

     

    ~J

    I agree. I drove to Seattle to get my Lackey coin and this makes it less special to me, even if it is a different coin from a different year. Will there be anything unique at all for people who visit the HQ now, or are they out of luck in lue of Groundspeak making a few extra bucks? At least I still have my volunteer coin.
  10. As long as it can be adopted over I think it's utterly silly to give the coin less of a value. If you don't like the past history of logs just delete them.

  11. I'm looking for these coins. If anyone has them available shoot me an email and maybe we can work something out. I don't care if they're activated as long as they can be adopted.

     

    2006 Rhode Island

    PA Keystone counties

    Ray & Rose

    2006 Australia

    GBES Rally

    Illegal Immigrant

    BelKen

     

    If there's any other coins with a kangaroo on them that I missed (aside from Kangacacher) I might be interested in those, too.

  12. If it's the Groundspeak Volunteer geocoin, it should already be activated. Do a trackables search using the tracking number to see if it's already activated.

     

     

    It is unactivated. It was donated by IowaAdmin to a CITO event last year for a prize drawing. I won it, and forgot about it until a few days ago when I found it in a box. Now I just need to know how to activate it.

    Giving this thread a bump because I have an unactivated 2005 Volunteer coin as well. Anyone know how to get the activation code?
  13. I've had a Calgary coin (#104) which I think is polished brass ever since they were made. I got 3 more recently and I'm a little stumped on which is which. My old one is a little tarnished so I don't know if I have two of the same metal or not. It looks like it's polished brass but it's pretty darn close to the polished gold, so with the tarnishing I'm just not sure. :D I've tried searching but can't find a list of what number ranges are made in what metal. I've got numbers 26, 104, 192 and 1178 now. Anyone know anything about the ranges?

×
×
  • Create New...