I am fairly new to geocaching. Last month, I was on a Cub Scout campout with my son and the Boy Scouts came out and introduced them to geocaching. My son and I are now hooked and it has provided us with some quality time together you could never buy. I just purchased, and recieved my first geocoin (literally a few hours ago) and guess which one it is? It is Mr Atwells design.
I've been in scouts for over 30 years now, and am currently a scout leader. I came into the forums to learn about geocoins and look what I stumble across. I'm not affiliated with either side on this issue, but would like to stress a few points about this thread. First, if I would have seen Mr Atwells acquisations and comments in this thread before I purchased the Scouting Coin, I never would have purchased the coin. Second, Mr Atwell attacks a scout troop for doing a fund raiser as a non-profit group when they make money doing it, that is the whole purpose of doing a fund raiser, and yes, it is still considered non-profit when they make money for a cause like this. Their production of their coin is nobel, the money is not going in anyone's pocket, but rather to promote a learning experience for young men. Your production of the coin is strictly FOR PROFIT. I don't care how many coins you donated to your own family's scout troop, the coins cost you nothing in the first place. Third, we're only talking about 100 coins that are very secific to only ONE Boy Scout Troop, how much damage, competition, or depreciation of Mr Atwells coin? Fourth, Mr Atwell brags about being an Eagle Scout, but I seriously wonder, his comments and actions do not reflect that of an Eagle Scout. I could go on, but I will leave this my final comment.
I bought the coin from the website looking at a small picture, after getting the coin, something about it reminded me of an eagle I've seem somewhere before, quite extensively, and almost exactly as the eagle on Mr Atwells coin. I don't know how to post a picture in a forum, but you can see dozens of the identical eagle at http://www.thirdreichruins.com/reichsadler.htm only the swastika is omitted on the coin.
This really should be a non-issue.