Bronzegoat, are you a numbers hider?
You can look at my profile and probably already have. I have 1,606 finds and 112 hides with a few of those having been archived (hmm, roughly the same find to hide percentage as well someone else). I probably have a total of three guardrail hides (that I can recall) and those were hidden with a purpose. I live in a very rural area in mountainous southwest Virginia and like most hiders in the area have caches along rural scenic roadways as well as up rough to very rough mountain roads. You can judge for yourself or check with people who have found my caches what type of hides they are. I can't fairly judge my own hides but I have found that most people (not all) tend to hide caches similar to the ones that they found when they first started caching (at least initially).
I have only used the forum a very few times and have read the guidelines but do not (perhaps out of ignorance) know which point you are referring to. I neither defend or attack individual hiders or seekers of any type because I think it is a person's own business how they decide to participate in a hobby. I just like many others get tired of people complaining about caching, hiding, seeking, numbers, quality of hides, contents of caches and everything else caching or cache related instead of just enjoying what has to be the greatest of hobbies and believe me I have had a lot of hobbies.